In this two-part series we talk about the importance of the sibling relationship. Here, in Part Two we focus on the pioneering work of Prophecy Coles in bringing the importance of this pivotal human relationship to our attention, primarily in her book “The Importance of Sibling Relationships in Psychoanalysis” (2003).

Learn more about this topic in our online CPD workshop: Siblings: same parents, different experience? with Victoria Settle on Friday 22nd November 2024, 10am – 4pm. Read Part 1 Blog here.

Prophecy Coles published her book “The Importance of Sibling Relationships in Psychoanalysis” in 2003 to a startled therapeutic world. She looked to explain how sibling relationships significantly shape our personality and emotional development. These interactions can impact self-esteem, identity, and social skills.

When the book was published one reviewer at the time commented:

‘Coles’ book starts from the claim that traditionally psychoanalysis, in stressing the relations of conflict between children and parents, has tended to overlook and displace the co-operative relations between siblings. This is a claim clearly worth investigating.’ – (Professor Richard Wollheim)

Prophecy Cole’s exploration of the dynamics of sibling relationships gives us a multifaceted examination of the psychological, emotional, and social dimensions that shape these important family connections. Below we’ve dipped into some of the key themes that Prophecy discusses in her book on Siblings, including the role of birth order, rivalry, support systems, and the impact of family structure.

The Importance of Birth Order 

Prophecy Cole’s research led her to understand the significance of birth order in shaping individual personalities and sibling interactions.

Firstborns often carry the weight of responsibility and high expectations, which can lead to traits such as leadership and perfectionism. Conversely, middle children may develop strong negotiation skills, striving to carve out their own identity within the family unit. Youngest siblings, often perceived as the “baby,” might adopt more playful or rebellious characteristics. 

These are not set roles in the family; what’s important to understand is that a child’s role may differ depending on where in the family they sit. Likewise, a person’s attachment style may differ depending on the birth order in the family.

The relationship of the firstborn to their Mother or main caregiver, when there may be no other significant attachment distractions for the Mother, is likely to be different from that of a child born third or fourth in a family where the parents have other small children to attend to.

These distinctions illustrate how siblings can serve as mirrors to each other, reflecting and reinforcing their roles based on their place in the birth order. Understanding these roles can help people navigate their relationships more effectively, fostering a deeper appreciation for each sibling’s unique contributions.

Rivalry and Competition

Sibling rivalry is another central theme. Sibling rivalry is a natural part of childhood development, and the arising conflict can lead to important learning experiences and emotional growth.The competitive nature of sibling relationships often stems from the quest for parental attention and approval. In her book Cole highlights that while rivalry can manifest in negative ways—such as jealousy or conflict—it can also lead to positive outcomes. Healthy competition can motivate siblings to excel and develop resilience.

She also suggests that navigating rivalry requires open communication and emotional intelligence. By fostering an environment where siblings feel valued and heard, families can mitigate the destructive aspects of rivalry, transforming it into a catalyst for growth.

Support Systems and Emotional Bonds

Sibling relationships are capable of providing profound support systems. In many families, siblings are each other’s confidants and allies, offering emotional support during challenging times. These relationships can serve as protective factors against mental health issues, as siblings often share experiences that foster empathy and understanding.

The emotional bonds between siblings can evolve over time, influenced by external factors such as life transitions, personal struggles, and changing family dynamics.

They may not always come naturally and maintaining these connections often requires intentional effort, particularly as individuals grow and pursue their own paths in life.

Family Structure and Its Impact

Prophecy Cole’s research on siblings also looks at how various family structures—such as single-parent families, blended families, and extended families—impact sibling relationships. 

For example, in single-parent households, siblings may take on additional responsibilities, leading to a unique bond forged through shared challenges. Blended families often require siblings to navigate new dynamics and negotiate their identities within the family unit.

The flexibility of sibling relationships can allow them to adapt to changing circumstances. Siblings can serve as anchors during tumultuous times, helping each other maintain a sense of belonging and continuity.

Communication Styles and Conflict Resolution

Effective communication is pivotal in maintaining healthy sibling relationships, and it is important that siblings develop their own communication styles, which can vary significantly based on personality and upbringing. For instance, some siblings may be direct and confrontational, while others may prefer to avoid conflict.

Understanding these differences is crucial for resolving disputes and fostering a harmonious-enough relationship.

Cultural Influences on Sibling Dynamics

Cultural context plays a significant role in shaping sibling relationships, a theme that Prophecy’s book explores in depth. 

In some cultures, siblings are expected to uphold familial obligations and maintain close-knit ties; while in others individuality and independence may be more highly valued. These expectations can influence not only sibling dynamics but also the way siblings perceive their roles within the family.

Understanding cultural influences allows individuals to appreciate the diversity of sibling experiences and fosters a broader perspective on what it means to be a sibling in different contexts.

Lifelong Relationships and Personal Growth

As individuals transition through various life stages—adolescence, adulthood, and even parenthood—their relationships with siblings can evolve but remain a foundational aspect of their lives.

The sibling relationship can offer unique insights into personal growth, resilience, and identity.

In adulthood, siblings often find themselves navigating new challenges together, such as aging parents or raising children. These shared experiences can deepen their connection and reinforce the notion that sibling relationships are lifelong commitments that evolve over time.

Therapeutic Implications

Throughout her book Prophecy Coles advocates for recognising the significance of sibling interactions in both individual and relational psychological frameworks. As therapists we can better understand the influences on those we work with by understanding sibling relationships alongside parent-child relationships. Prophecy Coles’ work has been fundamental in expanding the therapeutic appreciation of the depth of connection and estrangement that comes through the bond between sisters and brothers, relationships that can be both nurturing and fraught with tension.

Upcoming Workshop with Victoria Settle

Want to explore more? Join us for our upcoming workshop – Learn more about this topic in our online CPD workshop: Siblings: same parents, different experience? with Victoria Settle  on Friday 22nd November 2024, 10am – 4pm. 

In this presentation our trainers will guide us through some relevant theories and clinical considerations when we are working with someone who brings their sibling relationship to therapy.

Join our Therapy Community on Facebook

Brighton Therapy Partnership has a private Facebook Group for therapists which might be of interest to you if you are on social media? We currently have over 1.7k members. You will need to answer all 3 Joining Questions and agree to the Group Rules to join the Group!

Click Here to Join *The Therapy Partnership* Facebook Group – Be Part of the Therapy Community!

* There are affiliate links in this post, if you buy a book using one of these affiliate links we will get a very small fee. It all helps! Thank you!