Nov

3

2023

Legacy and Identity: Famous Replacement Children

Throughout history, many renowned figures in various fields, including William Shakespeare, Carl Jung and Elvis Presley, have been identified as “replacement children” – individuals born following the death of a sibling, and often perceived, or treated as a “replacement” for the lost child.

We have written the following article in preparation for our upcoming evening seminar: The ‘Replacement Child’ on Monday 19th February 2024, via Zoom from 6pm to 9pm UK time (with catch-up available), with expert speakers Kristina Schellinski and Dr Zack Eleftheriadou.

Famous Replacement Children

Image of Elvis Presley From Wikimedia Commons

The Replacement Child Forum highlights a large number of people who have been in the limelight, who were in fact Replacement Children. They include:

  • Elvis Presley
  • Frida Kahlo
  • Katherine Hepburn
  • William Shakespeare
  • Peter Sellers
  • Princess Diana
  • Sigmund Freud
  • Mark Twain
  • Carl Gustav Jung
  • Vincent van Gogh
  • Ludwig Von Beethoven
  • Salvador Dali
  • Maria Callas
  • Hermann Hesse
  • Noël Coward
  • Edvard Munch
  • Rainer Maria Rilke

 

Image of Frida Kahlo From Wikimedia Commons

For an even more extensive list: visit the Famous Replacement Children article on the Replacement Child Forum.

Defining ‘A Replacement Child’

In defining what it means to be a ‘replacement child’, The Replacement Child Forum recognises both a narrow, and broader definition:

“In a narrow definition a ‘replacement child’ is a child conceived and born to replace a child who died. Over the past 30 years, the concept has been broadened, to include the role attributed to a person, or the role a person self-identifies with.”

A person can be a replacement child if:

• Conceived or born to replace a child or other member of the family who has died;
• Born shortly after a death, stillbirth, miscarriage or abortion: a so-called subsequent child;
• Born as a surviving twin or multiple;
• Replacing a sibling or another member of the family later on, due to death or disability;
• In the context of the adoption of a child, replacing or being replaced by a conceived child; or
• Being assigned the role to replace a missing person or self-identifying with such a role.

Important Note: Children born or adopted after a death or loss are not automatically replacement children.

Challenges that may arise in being a Replacement Child

Being a replacement child can introduce a unique set of emotional and familial dynamics that can play a significant role in shaping an individual’s personality, ambitions, and accomplishments.

The Replacement Child Forum identifies challenges and issues that might be related to being a Replacement Child, including:

  • Relationship issues
  • Feeling Ill-at-ease in life
  • Low self-esteem
  • Not feeling good enough
  • Not feeling seen or heard
  • Rejection
  • Existential anxiety
  • Grief
  • Survivor’s guilt
  • In another’s shadow
Individuation and The Replacement Child

Individuation, a term popularised by Swiss psychiatrist Carl Jung (himself a Replacement Child), refers to the process by which an person becomes who they truly are, differentiating themselves from others and from the collective norms of society. He argued that this process is vital for personal development and self-realisation.

Replacement children, as individuals born following the death of a sibling, are especially likely to grapple with issues of identity, value, and self-worth.

They may unconsciously live in the shadow of the deceased sibling, feeling the need to live up to certain expectations or fill a void. In this way, we might imagine that they face unique challenges in their path to individuation. They may have feelings of guilt, unworthiness, or the weight of unspoken family grief.

A key part of their journey of self-discovery, will be in understanding their true selves apart from the identity of being a ‘replacement.’

This might include making use of potentially positive traits that might arise from being a replacement child.

Potentially “Positive” Traits

Heightened Sensitivity:

A replacement child may develop a heightened sensitivity to the emotions and needs of others, especially if they sense or are made aware of the grief their parents still carry. This emotional attunement can make them particularly empathetic and insightful, traits that can be beneficial in fields like psychology.

Drive to Prove Oneself:

Being aware of their status as a “replacement” might instil a drive in some, to prove their worth or to establish their own identity distinct from the deceased sibling. This can manifest as a determination to excel in chosen fields.

Deep Reflection:

The knowledge or subconscious awareness of being born after the loss of a sibling can lead to deep introspection and a quest for understanding life’s deeper meanings. This can be a driving force for those in fields that involve understanding human behaviour, motivations, or the psyche.

Strong Resilience:

Growing up with the unspoken grief of a family loss might foster resilience and a capacity to handle adversity. These individuals might develop a deeper appreciation for life’s challenges and the impermanence of life.

Unique Perspective:

Being a replacement child can offer a unique perspective on life, relationships, loss, and identity. This distinct viewpoint can be a source of creativity and innovation in various professions.

Desire for Connection:

The unspoken presence of a deceased sibling might lead to a strong desire for connection, whether it’s to understand the lost sibling, connect deeply with parents, or form bonds with others. This can be particularly beneficial in professions that require strong interpersonal skills or deep human understanding.

Famous Replacement Children in the Context of Psychology

In the realm of psychology, it is notable that several eminent personalities were replacement children. Understanding their backgrounds offers a unique perspective on their lives and contributions.

Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)

Image of Sigmund Freud From Wikimedia Commons

Regarded as the father of psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud was a replacement child. This loss may have impacted the dynamics of the Freud family, potentially influencing Freud’s own understanding of human behaviour and family relationships. Although Freud’s theories have been both lauded and critiqued over the years, his role as a replacement child offers a deeper insight into the personal experiences that may have shaped his work.

Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961)

Image of Carl Jung From Wikimedia Commons

Carl Gustav Jung, a Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who founded analytical psychology, was also born following the deaths of 3 older siblings. Jung’s exploration into the deeper aspects of the human psyche, including the collective unconscious and archetypes, could be seen in the light of his own personal experience of filling the void left by a deceased sibling.

Donald Winnicott (1896-1971)

Image of Donald Winnicott From Wikimedia Commons

Donald Winnicott, a British paediatrician and psychoanalyst, is best known for his work on transitional objects and the concept of the “good enough” mother. Winnicott’s experiences as a replacement child might have influenced his empathetic approach towards understanding child development and the significance of early relational experiences.

Melanie Klein (1882-1960)

Image of Melanie Klien From Wikimedia Commons

Melanie Klein, another influential figure in the world of psychoanalysis, specialised in child psychology. She introduced novel techniques in child psychoanalysis and had ground-breaking ideas about object relations theory. Melanie was 4 years old, when her older sister Sidonie, with whom she was very close, died of scrofula (tuberculous cervical lymphadenitis). It is likely that Klein’s personal experiences as a replacement child may have contributed to and deepened her insights into the complex world of child emotions and relationships.

Margaret Lawrence (1892-1974)

Image of Margaret Lawrence From Wikimedia Commons

Margaret Lawrence, the first African-American psychoanalyst and a prominent child psychiatrist, faced multifaceted challenges, both as a replacement child and as a trailblazer in a racially segregated America. Born after her parents lost her 11-month-old brother who died two years before she was born, Lawrence’s journey was shaped not only by the silent presence of a lost sibling but also by her determination to overcome societal barriers. Her accomplishments serve as a testament to her resilience and brilliance.

Conclusion

In conclusion, being a replacement child presents a unique set of emotional and familial dynamics. For these famous psychologists, their personal experiences may have been a driving force behind their passion to understand the human psyche. Their contributions to the field are invaluable, and understanding their backgrounds adds depth to their legacies.

Want to find out more about working with The Replacement Child?

Join Kristina Schellinski and Dr Zack Eleftheriadou for our upcoming evening seminar: The ‘Replacement Child’ on Monday 19th February 2024, via Zoom from 6pm to 9pm UK time (with catch-up available).

Latest Courses

Working with Complexity in Grief

Fri October 18th from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Friday 18th October 2024. ONLINE via Zoom and CATCH-UP for 28 days. Event Times: 10.00am – 4.00pm GMT (London)/ 11.00am – 5.00pm CET (Paris)/ 5.00am – 11.00am EST (New York).…

Internal Family Systems: An Introduction

Fri November 8th from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Friday 8th November 2024. ONLINE via Zoom and CATCH-UP for 28 days. Event Times: 10.00am – 4.00pm GMT (London)/ 11.00am – 5.00pm CET (Paris)/ 5.00am – 11.00am EST (New York).…

Siblings: same parents, different experience?

Fri November 22nd from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Friday 22nd November 2024. ONLINE via Zoom and CATCH-UP for 28 days. Event Times: 10.00am – 4.00pm GMT (London)/ 11.00am – 5.00pm CET (Paris)/ 5.00am – 11.00am EST (New York).…

Get 20% off your first training course

Receive free training updates, special offers, and expert articles straight to your inbox! You'll also get a 20% discount off a full price ticket for your first online event.

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Get 25% off your first training course

Receive free training updates, special offers, and expert articles straight to your inbox! You'll also get a 25% discount off a full price ticket for your first online event.

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Leave a Comment





Before submitting, please take note of our community guidelines.